Hi all,

I'm using ST's CubeMX implementation on a F4 discovery board. I use ST's USB middlewares with FreeRTOS.

When I get a special OutputReport from PC side I have to answer nearly immediately (in 10-15 ms). Currently I cannot achieve this timing and it seems my high priority tasks can interrupt the USB callback. What do you think, is it possible? Because it's generated code I'm not sure but can I increase the priority of the USB interrupt (if there is any)?

Thank you, David

10 to 15 ms is very slow, so I'm sure its possible.

Where is the USB callback function called from? If it is an interrupt then it cannot be interrupted by high priority RTOS tasks. Any non interrupt code (whether you are using an RTOS or not) can only run if no interrupts are running.

Without knowing the control flow in your application its hard to know what to suggest. How is the OutputReport communicated to you? By an interrupt, a message from another task, or some other way?

The callback which receive the data from PC is called from the OTGFSIRQHandler (it's the part of the HALPCDIRQHandler function). I think the problem is SysTickHandler's priority is higher than OTGFSIRQHandler and it's cannot be modified, but the scheduler shouldn't interrupt the OTGFSIRQHandler with any task handled by the scheduler. Am I wrong that the scheduler can interrupt the OTGFS_IRQHandler?

Introductiontoelectroniccircuitdesignspencerpdf Best

How different circuits actually work from a fundamental perspective.

Introduction to Electronic Circuit Design by Richard R. Spencer and Mohammed S. Ghausi is a standard two-volume text for upper-level engineering courses. It is highly regarded for focusing on first principles and intuition rather than just "rules of thumb". Amazon.com

: Pair your reading with a free SPICE simulator like LTspice. Recreate the textbook's schematic examples to see how changing resistor or transistor values alters circuit behavior.

While many books treat SPICE simulation as an afterthought or a separate chapter, this text integrates simulation throughout. It teaches the student how to properly use simulation tools to verify hand calculations—a vital skill in modern industry.

for quick reference and portability. While digital versions are incredibly convenient for searching specific terms or studying on the go, having a physical copy is often preferred for the detailed circuit diagrams and end-of-chapter problems that require deep focus. Final Verdict introductiontoelectroniccircuitdesignspencerpdf best

When studying electrical engineering, having the right textbook makes a massive difference. Introduction to Electronic Circuit Design by Richard R. Spencer and Mohammed S. Ghausi is highly regarded for its clear explanations of analog and digital circuits. If you are searching for this textbook, supplemental materials, or solutions, understanding what resources are available—and how to access them legally—will save you hours of study time. Why the Spencer and Ghausi Textbook Stand Out

The book is renowned for its pedagogical structure. It often presents concepts in two passes:

Many textbooks treat Bipolar Junction Transistors (BJTs) and Complementary Metal-Oxide-Semiconductors (CMOS) as separate species. Spencer merges them. He shows that while the physics differs, the design strategies are analogous. This is crucial for modern IC design where chips use both technologies (BiCMOS).

Small-signal mid-frequency analysis. Use the PDF alongside a SPICE simulator (like LTSpice, which is free). Replicate Figure 6.34 from the PDF to see if your simulation matches the book. How different circuits actually work from a fundamental

Reading an engineering textbook passively is ineffective. Use this structured approach to master the material in the Spencer PDF:

For those on a budget, used copies are often available at a fraction of the original price. Additionally, check with your university library. Many academic libraries still carry this textbook, and some may offer digital access through their online portals. As noted in the search results, "introduction to electronic circuit design - 2 volume set" is a common description.

them. This practical "design-oriented" approach is what sets it apart from purely theoretical manuals. Clarity and Flow:

: For students self-studying, finding the official "Solutions Manual" is the best way to verify work on the challenging end-of-chapter design problems. specific topics Ghausi is a standard two-volume text for upper-level

Not all search results for engineering PDFs are safe or helpful. Use these guidelines to find the best materials:

When searching online for introductiontoelectroniccircuitdesignspencerpdf best , it is important to navigate the internet safely and ethically.

When looking for the best digital version of this textbook for your studies, ensure it meets these quality standards: Low-Quality PDF High-Quality (Best) PDF Scanned images (cannot highlight) Digital text (OCR enabled) Navigation Scroll-only Interactive Table of Contents Schematics Blurry, unreadable component labels Vector graphics or high-res images Index Flat image pages Hyperlinked page numbers Tips for Studying Electronic Circuit Design

The Spencer/Ghausi text is highly regarded for several key reasons: Integrated Design Perspective

Thank you for the answer, I think I'm a bit confused with the Cortex ISR priorities :-) What I can observe is if I use a much higher osDelay in my high priority task I can respond for the received USB message much faster. This is why I think tasks can mess up with my OTG interrupt.