Muawiyah, acknowledging the truth of the rebuke, famously replied: .
The regarding how the Sahaba handled internal criticism.
The Prophet (ﷺ) advised him to use the money for food and clothing.
Al-Miqdam's first question to Muawiyah concerned the wearing of gold. The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) explicitly forbade men from adorning themselves with gold, a ruling consistently maintained across all schools of Islamic jurisprudence. abu dawood 4131 fixed
(Note: The full, detailed exchange regarding these prohibitions and the mention of Al-Hasan ibn Ali can be found in the referenced documents). Sunnah.com Summary of Prohibitions Mentioned
The hadith is directly linked to the Prophet Muhammad through Abu Hurairah, a well-known companion of the Prophet. Abu Dawood, the compiler, recorded this hadith in his collection.
Understanding Abu Dawood 4131: Text, Context, and Scholarly Grading Muawiyah, acknowledging the truth of the rebuke, famously
return hadith_data
The narration clarifies that begging is only appropriate for those with extreme, unmanageable debt, extreme poverty, or those who must pay blood money.
In the chain, Imam Abu Dawood records: Musaddad → Abu ‘Awanah → Simak → ‘Ikrimah → Ibn ‘Abbas. Wait—the text mentions Al-Rabi’, but the chain ends at Ibn ‘Abbas. This discrepancy causes confusion. Scholars like pointed out that the text found in some manuscripts does not match the chain. The connection between the narrator Simak and ‘Ikrimah is also questionable, as Simak was known for Tadlis (ambiguity in transmission). Al-Miqdam's first question to Muawiyah concerned the wearing
Online researchers frequently use the keyword "fixed" when dealing with discrepancies in Islamic database indexing. In Sunan Abi Dawud, chapter names and numbers vary between traditional publishing houses. Database / Edition Hadith Focus for #4131 Chapter Classification Al-Miqdam, Mu'awiyah, and Clothing Prohibitions Kitab Al-Libas (Book of Clothing) Alternate / Legacy Print Indexes Jabir ibn Samurah reclining on a pillow Chapter on Bedding / Sitting Etiquette
is a hadith found in the Book of Clothing (Kitab Al-Libas)
that teach similar economic lessons. Let me know how you'd like to further explore this subject . Share public link